Pizza restaurants

Matoli's Pizza & Subs

4.4 230 reviews Closed 3211 Shoal Line Blvd, Hernando Beach, FL 34607, United States

Discover this place

Located at 3211 Shoal Line Blvd in Hernando Beach, Matoli's Pizza & Subs has quickly become a local favorite, renowned for its exceptional Chicago-style deep dish pizzas. Customers rave about the rich, sweet sauce that adorns their pies, which include a variety of specialties such as the Matoli Mega Supreme and the unique Eggplant pizza.

Madison Gould praises the massive portions and the quality of their Greek salad, while others echo sentiments of unparalleled taste and value. Dynamic Surveillance & Communications LLC describes it as the best they've ever experienced, showcasing Matoli's impact even beyond Hernando Beach. The homemade calzones are also a standout, garnering high praise from regulars like NATURE MARINA, who appreciate the consistent quality and generous sizes.

Despite being primarily a grab-and-go establishment, the culinary experience at Matoli's is anything but rushed. Each bite of their deep dish and stuffed shells speaks to a family-owned passion for good food. Whether you’re a fan of classic meat lovers or want to explore their veggie options, Matoli's promises a memorable meal that will keep you coming back for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Matoli's Pizza & Subs before visiting.

Reviews for Matoli's Pizza & Subs

4.4

230 reviews

100%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 230 reviews

Matoli's Pizza & Subs in Hernando Beach is widely praised for its authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza, which stands out as a unique offering in the area. Customers frequently highlight the flavorful, well-balanced sauce and generous portion sizes. The menu’s homemade calzones and garlic cheese bread also receive positive mentions for quality and taste. While primarily a grab-and-go establishment, the food’s quality and value consistently impress patrons. Family-owned, the restaurant enjoys strong local support, with repeat customers appreciating the combination of traditional recipes and reasonable pricing. Some feedback notes that certain desserts may be overly sweet for some tastes, but overall, Matoli's maintains a reputation for satisfying hearty, flavorful meals.

Madison Gould

Jun 29, 2025

Such great pizza! The only place in the area with Chicago deep dish and it did not disappoint! The sauce has a really nice sweetness to it. We also got the Greek salad and it was huge! The garlic cheese bread is good as well! It’s only a grab and go place. Will definitely be back!

Dynamic Surveillance & Communications LLC.

Jun 19, 2025

I was working in Hernando Beach and ordered Mattoli’s for lunch. It is by far the best I have eaten in my 49 years on this earth. I will definitely be driving to Hernando from Spring Hill whenever my family or I are wanting !!!

Michael Stafford

Jun 16, 2025

Ordered a meat lovers Chicago style pizza and it was really good. I’ve always been a thin crust kinda guy but I think I’m gonna have to give deep dish a try for a while.

NATURE MARINA

Apr 22, 2025

Family owned and operated. They have the BEST homemade calzones, I work on the beach and order from them at least once a week. They have the best pizza, calzones and anything else I have ordered, I have never been disappointed. Great prices for the quality and size of food.

Laurie Hrh

Apr 16, 2025

First time trying it tonight , it was fantastic! We got the Chicago deep dish and really enjoyed it . We also got a cannoli and that was to sweet for our taste but the pizza was great

Baby St Clair

Apr 15, 2025

New to Hernando Beach and desperate to find comfort food... found absolute bliss with the pizzas we had delivered! The White Pizza and the Meat lovers Chicago style were both a perfect choice. Delivered hot and fast. Well not hesitate or think twice about ordering here again.

Marc Molella

Apr 11, 2025

Awesome authentic Chicago style deep dish pizza. Grew up in Chicago and am happy I found Matoli's. Finally a taste of home here in Florida. The cheesy garlic bread was excellent as well. The sauce is very flavorful as we're the two items. Has now become one of my regular places for pizza.